WASHINGTON D.C. - The National Federation of Filipino American Associations (NaFFAA), the voice of 3 million Filipino Americans in the United States, has joined the chorus of protest against the district attorney of Camden County, Georgia for holding an accused doctor in detention for almost a year without recourse to bail.
In a recent letter to District Attorney Stephen Kelley of Camden county, Georgia, NaFFAA chair Alma Quintans Kern took up the cudgels for Dr. Romeo Natividad Chua, a Far Eastern University graduate, who has been implicated in the death of an American patient and has been in jail since September last year.
After so many postponements, the trial of
Dr. Chua has now been set for September 10.
In her letter to DA Kelley, Ms. Kern
said: “We find it disturbing that Dr. Chua was not afforded his fundamental
‘due process’ rights, was denied access to his legal counsel - along with your
seizing his assets, rendering him unable to pay his lawyer’s and
witnesses’ fees,” Ms Kern said, adding “He was denied bail and as since been
incarcerated for the last 7 and 1/2 months because you considered him a ‘flight
risk.’ Ironically, however, we find it disingenuous that you’re alleged to have
offered him a plea bargain to admit to just one drug charge and take a 2-year
sentence.”
Dr. Chua has been charged for his alleged
involvement in the death of James Carter III in December, 2005. An autopsy
report held that Mr. Carter’s death was accidental, caused by the mixture of
drugs ingested by the deceased.
Furthermore, toxicology report showed
that the drugs found in the deceased were found to be all within the
therapeutic level, including “methadone,” as prescribed by Dr. Chua.
“Despite the above findings, however, and
after a 9-month long investigation, he was subsequently arrested on September
13, 2006, and charged with the murder of Mr. Carter, along with his alleged
violations of Georgia’s
Controlled Substance Act," the NaFFAA chair said.
She said “we believe that every American
- including U.S.
citizen Dr. Noel Chua - should have the basic right to challenge his arrest via
a time-tested habeas corpus petition. Instead, you stripped him of that right,
and it’s becoming apparent to s that your office rigged the Georgia justice
system’s rules of procedures squarely against him."
“With all due respect, we contend that
your stance on his case is so severely flawed that it makes one think that the
kind of justice system you’re overseeing in Camden County is so tainted — if
not racially biased and/or glaringly discriminatory against a
Filipino-American, who has dutifully served his St. Mary’s community with his
utmost professionalism and integrity, philanthropy and countless works of mercy
- as attested to by the thousands of patients and citizens he has helped and
cared for all these years," Ms Kern said.
She pointed out that Dr. Chua did not
succumb to the DA’s offer of plea
bargain. “We’re proud of him that he chose to remain in prison rather than admit
the guilt of a crime he did not commit.”
She continued: “What would be purported
to be specific statements of facts may even lack the most fundamental earmarks
of objective credible evidence amidst your unwillingness to consider
exculpatory evidence that would have granted him his request for bail, if not
his outright release from incarceration."
Lastly, the hallmark of our American Court
system is etched in these words that ‘... justice delayed is justice denied.’
Accordingly, we are thankful that, after such a long wait, he will at
long last see his day in Court on September 10, 2007. Rest assured that
Filipino-American leaders from NaFFAA and other organizations in Georgia and across the U.S. will be
present to rigorously scrutinize how you would mete out the fiat of American
justice.
“We the Filipino-Americans across Georgia and America
are very much opposed to the way you’ve handled the case of Dr. Noel
Natividad-Chua — an honorable Filipino-American citizen and a distinguished
member of Georgia’s Camden County.
Under Georgia’s Court system of justice
and the guidance of the U.S. Constitution, we look forward to witnessing this
trial."
The Georgia Asian Times said in its
latest issue that supporters of Dr. Chua are relieved that he will finally have
his day in court. It said the Filipino American community in Georgia has
galvanized efforts in recent weeks to get the authorities to free Dr. Chua on
bail or to have the case set for trial.
“We are glad that the case will go to
trial in court after almost a year. We are confident and optimistic on the
outcome of this trial," said Willy Blanco, VP of Fil-Am of Atlanta, a local
Filipino-American community organization.
Over $100,000 has been raised to date by
the supporters of Dr. Chua to help pay for his legal defense, according to
Blanco. “We plan to raise another $25,000 to help pay for legal fees and
medical expert witnesses."
“We are outraged at the way Dr. Chua was
treated initially and why he is in jail for so long, and being denied bond when
there are other far more heinous cases that have been granted bail," said
Dr. Ely Ellebera, a local physician and a supporter.
Prosecutors have tried to get Dr. Chua to
accept a plea bargain of probation in exchange of a guilty plea to a lesser
charge of violating Georgia’s Controlled Substance Act, but Chua flatly
rejected the offer and demanded his day in court.
He was also charged with RICO (Racketeer
Influenced and Corrupt Organization) that gave the authorities the power to
take control of all his assets.
Dr. Chua is represented by Attorney
Donald Samuel, a Georgia
criminal law expert who has published numerous books and journals on criminal law. He reportedly told
the Filipino-American community leaders that “there is no case against Dr.
Chua” and that the death of Carter was “accidental,” as supported by the
autopsy and toxicology reports.
One of Dr. Chua’s local supporter and
strong advocate is none other than Sheriff Bill Smith of Camden County.
Sheriff Smith befriended Dr. Chua and traveled with him to China to seek
alternative treatment for his son in early 2006. Smith’s son is paralyzed from
an automobile accident.
The sheriff admitted on July 17 at a
Camden County Commission meeting that he is somewhat caught in the middle of
the case.
Prosecutors filed a motion on July 26 in
an attempt to move the trial out of Camden
County. Assistant
District Attorney Jackie Johnson filed a motion to recuse Sheriff Smith due to
his advocacy for Dr. Chua. The motion also said Dr. Chua is ‘not secure in the Camden County
Detention Center."
The GAT said the Filipino-American
community continues to rally support and organize fund raising effort to help
pay for the doctor?s legal defense expenses. “We hope to increase the moral
support from the general public and the community’s letter writing campaign to
the District Attorney office about the injustice," said Blanco who visits
with Dr. Chua regularly.
“The death of James Carter is unfortunate,
but what happened to Dr. Chua is a terrible injustice. If such injustice could
happen to Dr. Chua, it could happen to anyone including you and me," added
Blanco.
The 47-year old Dr. Chua has an
impeccable personal and professional background. He was a high school
valedictorian, magna cum laude in Medical Technology, Number 1 in the Med-Tech
Board in 1987, and a consistent honor student.
He graduated from the Far Eastern
University Medical School in Manila,
Number 11 in the Medical Board. He had highest distinction honors after
completing his Master?s degree in Health Care Policy and Management from Carnegie Mellon University.
Last month, Dr. Chua gave an exclusive
interview to Edmund Silvestre of the weekly Filipino Reporter in New York, complaining of
how his constitutional rights were trampled and how he intends to fight till
the end to restore his dignity and reputation.
The Reporters story said “Dr. Noel Chua
is angry, desperate and helpless. For close to a year now, the
Filipino-American Georgia physician, who is a medical graduate ofthe Far
Eastern University in Manila and ranked 11th in the 1992 board exam, remains
locked up as his legal troubles drag on with no end in sight.
In the interview, Dr. Chua said he was a
friend of the family of Mr. Carter and had hired him as a filing clerk and to
assist patients. He said he only became aware of his drug history from his
family after his death.
The doctor was accused of murder after
Carter died from ingesting prescribed and unprescribed drugs. “They charged me with murder saying the drugs I prescribed
had no legitimate medical purpose," he said.
Asked why he was charged, Dr. Chua said
“It’s all about abuse of power on the part of the authorities to help a family
(Carter’s) shift their guilt to someone else. There’s also racial
discrimination. The DA has other motives than to accept the truth that James
Carter was responsible for his actions. The DA, with the help of the chief
investigator, misled the grand jury to believing I prescribed medications without
any legitimate medical purpose based on one other doctor’s affidavit. But the
toxicology report alone shows there were drugs in James Carter’s system that I
did not prescribe and were not supposed to be mixed together."
Asked why he rejected the plea bargain
offer, the doctor said “I’d rather go to prison than admit to a lie.”
The doctor also recounted how he was
transferred to another county jail because the authorities knew I would be
treated fairly in Camden
county where he had established a good practice with more than 1,000 patients.
He said: “The law requires that I should
be detained in the county where I reside but the DA requested the judge to sign
an order to transport me to Glynn County which is about 35-40 miles away from Camden County
. They know I would be treated fairly in Camden
County so they took me to Glynn County
to be maltreated there. I stayed there for approximately six weeks and had
minimal contact with family and friends. My lawyer found the Georgia Code that
they violated, and he filed a motion asking the DA to provide a valid reason
why I was taken to Glynn
County . The DA could not
justify his action so the judge was forced to sign an order to bring me back to
Camden."
Dr. Chua said his “assets have been
seized and a receiver was appointed by the court after he was falsely accused
of racketeering, clearly an attempt to prevent me from financing my defense. I
never did any racketeering activity. This receiver was allowed to charge my
account for their services in unbelievable amounts to drive my finances to
zero. They had already forced me to sell one of my investment properties. They
were forcing me to sell my house or office."
He added that before his arrest, he had
over $120,000 in cash in the bank. The last statement he received from the
receiver showed his account was down to about $10,000.
“I cannot believe that they can charge me
or use up my money when they haven’t convicted me. The court appointed them so
the court should have been paying them, but the receiver has already withdrawn
over $50,000 from my account for themselves, not specified as fees or
anything," he told the Reporter.
Dr. Chua said that since this happened to
him, “it could happen to anybody. We really eed to think more about people who
are falsely imprisoned.”
He said his parents in Manila could not believe what was happening
to him.
Dr. Chua also appealed to the community
to help him “against this discrimination
and injustice.”