WASHINGTON D.C.-Instead of immigration reforms that included the possibility of citizenship for some 11 million illegal aliens, the Senate approved the House measure that would build a fence in the border to Mexico.
The measure was sent to President bush who had earlier promised to sign a comprehensive immigration reform measure. He is expected to approve fence measure, dealing a final blow this year to the comprehensive immigration reform measure that was passed by the Senate several months ago.
House Republicans, fearing a voter
backlash, had opposed any approach that smacked of amnesty and chose instead to
focus on border security in advance of the elections, passing the fence bill
earlier this month.
With time running out, the Senate
acquiesced despite its bipartisan passage of a broader bill in May.
Congress also passed a separate $34.8
billion homeland security spending bill that contained an estimated $21.3
billion for border security, including $1.2 billion for the fence and
associated barriers and surveillance systems.
“This is something the American people
have been wanting us to do for a long time," said Senator Jon Kyl,
Republican of Arizona, whose state would be the site of substantial fence construction.
Homeland Security Secretary Michael
Chertoff praised the money for border security. He said it would ‘enable the
department to make substantial progress toward preventing terrorists and others
from exploiting our borders and provides flexibility for smart deployment of
physical infrastructure that needs to be built along the southwest
border."
Democrats, as expected, ridiculed the
fence idea and said a broader approach was the only way to stop further illegal
immigration. “You don’t have to be a law enforcement or engineering expert to
know that a 700-mile fence on a 2,000-mile border makes no sense,” said Senator
Richard J. Durbin of Illinois, the second-ranking Democrat in the Senate.
Nevertheless, more than 20 Democrats moved behind the measure.
The fence bill and homeland spending were
among security-related measures the Republican leadership was pushing through
in the closing hours to bolster their security credentials.
Senator Saxby Chambliss, Republican of
Georgia, said the vote would build credibility with conservative voters who
have been skeptical of the government’s commitment to border security.
But Republicans and Democrats alike
acknowledged they were leaving the country’s immigration problems largely
unresolved. The border security measures passed do not address the 11 million
people living here illegally, the call for a guest worker program by businesses
or the need for a verification program that would ensure that companies do not
hire illegal workers.
Instead of trying to reconcile its
version of the bill with the more
liberal bill approved by the Senate, the House leadership is pressing with its
campaign to reinforce the borders after key lawmakers met recently to assess
the critical situation in border states. Based on their report, the House has
filed a bill increasing the length of the double fence in the south.
Both proponents of the Senate bill and
advocacy groups are agreed that a compromise bill will be approved even after
the elections in November. It will be up to the next Congress to revive the
bill, if ever.
The attempt to revive the May nationwide
rally in favor of illegal aliens has ended in failure as pessimism among
advocates has become more pronounced.
The plea of Sen. Edward M. Kennedy,
D-Mass., a leading architect of a bipartisan immigration bill in the Senate,
for Bush to make an all-out push to rescue the bill before lawmakers quit work
to campaign for the Nov. 7 congressional elections went unheeded.
The Senate bill, supported by President
Bush, includes a guest-worker program, eventual legalization of the some 12
million illegal aliens already in the US, and toughened enforcement and border
security. The House favors cracking down on illegal aliens, stronger border
enforcement and other tough measures against violators of US immigration laws.
The House, where its more than 430
members are all up for reelection was in no mood to pass the comprehensive
immigration bill.
“I fear that the incentive to demagogue
the issue and use it as a political football is going to be greater than the
willingness to legislate," said Cecilia Munoz, vice president of the
National Council of La Raza, the nation’s largest Latino civil rights
organization.
If the current 109th Congress fails to
act on immigration by the end of the year, the president would have to start
over after the next Congress convenes in early January, when his presidential
powers would presumably be on the wane during his final two years in office.
Many believe that Bush’s ability to influence legislation has already suffered
with his decline in the polls.