WASHINGTON D.C. – Filipino Americans have expressed their outrage over the “detention” of a Filipino American activists in Manila on Aug. 5. Their anger has not subsided even after reports came that Prof. Annalisa Vicente Enrile, chair of GABRIELA-USA and professor of Southern California University, was finally allowed to leave.
Dennis Garcia, husband of Professor Annalisa Vicente Enrile, said she returned from Manila Aug. 14, nine days after she was stopped from leaving Aug. 4 by Philippine authorities because she was on the “watchlist.”
Garcia
said he talked to her by phone after the Philippine Department of
Justice signed papers removing her and two other activists -
writer-journalist Ninotchka Rosca and Judith Mirkinson - from the
hold order.
On
Aug. 13, Lisa and Nilo Enrile, the parents of Prof. Enrile met with
Consul General Mary Jo Bernardo Aragon and Consul Noemi Diaz. They
were accompanied by Maureen Ivy Quicho, GABNet Coordinator for Los
Angeles.
They
were assured by Aragon that they will be informed of development from
Manila.
Annalisa’s
parents expressed disappointment that the US embassy in Manila did
not help her because they said it was a local matter. Instead,
Annalisa was given a list of lawyers to contact in Manila.
“My
daughter is not a criminal,” Mr. Enrile told Mrs. Aragon. “My
daughter is a humanitarian. She always fights for the poor and for
causes like human trafficking and domestic violence.”
“It’s
clear that the Philippine government, led by Gloria Macapagal Arroyo,
is desperately trying to intimidate and silence international
solidarity," GABNet Secretary Doris Mendoza said, “especially
those focusing on the countless human rights violations and political
killings. But our membership and allies are now even more determined.
For
us, the harassment of the GABNet 3 reconfirms the undemocratic and
unjust character of this US-backed Macapagal Arroyo regime" the
GABNet prepared statement said.
On
Aug. 14, Doy Heredia of National Federation of Filipino American
Associations (NaFFAA) called Philippine embassy Deputy Chief of
Mission King Sorreta to ask why Prof. Enrile and two other activists
- writer-journalist Ninotchka Rosca and American human rights
activist Judith Mirkinson - were prevented from leaving Manila
allegedly because they were on the “watchlist.”
Heredia
said that up to Aug. 17, he did not receive any response from the
embassy or from Sorreta. Jon Melegrito said NaFFAA will release an
“appropriate statement” if the three are still being prevented
from returning to the US.
Reme
Grefalda, editor of Ezine, an internet magazine, has contacted other
leaders and the media to comment and write about this issue. In her
email to other leaders, Reme said: “Who is safe from this type of
intimidation. It can happen to one of us anytime.” Maurese Owens of
the Philippine American Foundation for Charities (PAFC) expressed
her “outrage” over this incident. Their virtual detention has
also infuriated hundreds of human rights activists in the US, Canada
and around the world. They accused the Philippine government of
harassment, illegal detention and intimidation.
Sonny
San Juan, well known author, said from his home in Connecticut: “I
found myself being afraid, very much afraid - for myself and other
expatriate Filipinos who are not exactly admirers of the winsome ways
of this administration.
“And
who would not be, if you, on your return to the beloved Inang Bayan
for a short vacation from work in some foreign country, find yourself
in the predicament of Dr. Annalisa Enrile?"
So
whatever happened to the right to travel that is supposed to be the
primogeniture of the world-famous OFW, whose obsession with that
“extra dollar” has impelled his wanderlust to toil in the harsh
deserts of the Middle East, and other alien places all over the
globe? It is all too clear that no one can be prevented from leaving
the country, unless one has committed a crime and charges have been
filed before the courts. I’ve got news for all OFWs: Under the HSA,
you can be held on mere suspicion or association with groups openly
critical of the government.
Surprisingly,
not many of the Manila media published her story although she held a
press conference.
Copies
of the letter of Annalisa to Ambassador Kenney have been distributed
widely to leaders in the United States and Canada. She was part of an
international group that met in Manila to take up the issue of human
rights violations in the Philippines.
In
her letter to Ambassador Kenney, Annalisa asked for the embassy’s
assistance “because the Philippine government is refusing to let me
return to the United States even though I know of no charges or cases
against my person.”
“Furthermore,
I have been and am being shuffled from the Department of Justice to
the Bureau of Immigration to some office called NICA.
Since
August 5, 2007 when I was stopped from boarding my flight home, I
have not been told any specific reason as to why I am being prevented
from returning to my home country.
“My
human and civil rights are being violated by this surrealist
procedure dictated by some unknown entity/person. This is causing me
extreme distress, as well as jeopardizing my professional standing
and causing me financial hardship.
“As
I have not made provisions to stay in the Philippines beyond August
5, I am practically a homeless person, dependent on the good will of
friends for my board and lodging.
“I
am of mind to sue whoever gave the ”hold" order for actual and
punitive damages, which are accumulating daily. It would be good if
the Embassy can help me find out the basis for this hold order and
its veracity, as well as its origins so that I may seek justice."
Party
list congresswomen said this may be part of the government’s
enforcement of the anti-terrorism Human Security Act which allows
security agencies to hold anyone on suspicion of being a terrorist.
In
a press conference Aug. 11 in Quezon City, Enrile said she believes
she is being held because of her involvement with GABRIELA and for
being part of a team that went to the country to probe the human
rights record of the Arroyo administration.
“I’m
being held hostage,” Enrile told the media. “I cannot go back to
my work and my family."